Since 1887. Made Fresh Daily.

Mackinac Island Fudge & Sweet Treats

At The Fudge Factory, we craft our legendary fudge using an original 1887 recipe from Martha Murdick of Mackinac Island. We also offer rich caramel corn, crunchy peanut brittle, and decadent chocolate-covered pretzels and cookies – all made fresh in-store for an unforgettable taste of tradition.

Explore Our Sweets play icon Learn More

Mackinac Island Fudge

Handmade daily using an authentic 1887 recipe – creamy, rich, and unforgettable.

Caramel Corn & Peanut Brittle

Sweet, buttery, and perfectly crunchy – the perfect gift or personal indulgence.

Chocolate Covered Treats

Pretzels, cookies, and more, dipped in smooth, decadent chocolate made in-store.

handmade fudge in Plainwell, MI
About Us

About The Fudge Factory

The Fudge Factory is a locally owned sweet shop carrying on the Mackinac Island fudge tradition, we're passionate about creating confections that delight every customer.

From our signature fudge to our handcrafted brittle and chocolate treats, everything we make reflects quality, tradition, and flavor you won't forget.

"My mission is to honor an iconic recipe and share our love for old-fashioned sweets with every visitor. We believe in making everything with care – just like Martha did in 1887."

Mark W. Aronoff Owner quote icon
More About Us
Mackinac Island Fudge in Plainwell, MI
Tradition Meets Taste

Why Choose The Fudge Factory

For over a century, this fudge recipe has delighted generations. We continue that legacy with handmade sweets that bring joy to every bite.

Whether you're a local or visiting Plainwell, MI, we promise a taste you'll come back for again and again.

View Our Sweet Selections →
Our Reviews

What Our Customers Say

We're proud to be part of Plainwell, MI's sweet tradition. Here's what our customers have to say:

  • The best fudge I've ever had! So creamy and flavorful – I take some home every visit.

    Sarah P. Customer

  • The caramel corn is addictive, and the peanut brittle tastes like childhood memories. Amazing place!

    James C. Customer

Ready to Taste Tradition?

Visit The Fudge Factory today or order online for authentic Mackinac Island fudge and handcrafted sweets.

Order Now
Mackinac Island fudge display